Classic Pokémon Arrives on Switch, But Is It Worth It?

The Pokémon Company is bringing Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen to the Nintendo Switch for $20 each. These are direct ports of the Game Boy Advance versions, offering original gameplay with local wireless connectivity. However, the high price point and comparison to Nintendo Switch Online's classic library raise questions about value.

5 days ago
3 min read

Pokémon’s Nostalgic Play Hits Switch, But With a Catch

The Pokémon Company is bringing the beloved Game Boy Color classics, Pokémon FireRed and Pokémon LeafGreen, to the Nintendo Switch. However, this isn’t the full-blown remaster many fans might have hoped for. Instead, players will get the original Game Boy experience, albeit with a modern convenience: local wireless play replacing the need for a physical link cable. Each game will retail for a steep $20.

A Faithful, Yet Unenhanced, Re-release

Fans eager to relive the Kanto region adventures will find FireRed and LeafGreen presented in their original form. This means no graphical overhaul, no new gameplay mechanics, and no quality-of-life improvements beyond the ability to connect with friends wirelessly for trading and battling. This approach mirrors previous digital re-releases of classic Pokémon titles, such as Pokémon Gold and Silver on the 3DS eShop, which, in Japan, even came with elaborate physical packaging that included a download code.

The Pricey Proposition of Nostalgia

At $20 per game, the digital re-release of FireRed and LeafGreen raises eyebrows, especially when compared to other options available to Nintendo Switch owners. While an authentic physical copy of these Game Boy Advance titles can command prices upwards of $150 on the collector’s market, the digital version offers accessibility at a significant markup compared to other classic game offerings on the Switch platform.

Nintendo Switch Online vs. Standalone Releases

A major point of contention is the pricing strategy when juxtaposed with the Nintendo Switch Online service. For a subscription fee, players gain access to a growing library of classic Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) and Super Nintendo Entertainment System (SNES) games, including several Pokémon titles. Recently, The Pokémon Company announced that Pokémon Stadium, Pokémon Stadium 2, Pokémon Crystal, and the Nintendo 64 titles Pokémon Snap and Pokémon: The Crystal Shards are coming to the Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack service. Furthermore, the service has already made titles like Pokémon XD: Gale of Darkness and Pokémon Colosseum available, offering a substantial collection of older Pokémon games without individual purchase.

The decision to price FireRed and LeafGreen at $20 each, while other classic Pokémon games are included as part of a subscription service, feels like a missed opportunity to offer greater value to loyal fans. This pricing model makes the standalone digital releases appear less appealing, especially for those who are already subscribed to Nintendo Switch Online.

Who Should Buy These Games?

These re-releases are primarily aimed at the most dedicated Pokémon fans who wish to experience the original Game Boy Advance versions of FireRed and LeafGreen on their current-generation console. If you have a deep sentimental attachment to these specific titles and are willing to pay a premium for the convenience of playing them on the Switch, then this might be for you. It’s also an option for players who missed out on these games during their initial release and want to experience them in their purest form, without the modifications found in remakes like FireRed and LeafGreen.

However, for the casual fan or those already invested in the Nintendo Switch Online service, the value proposition is questionable. The inclusion of other, arguably more complex or sought-after, Pokémon titles within the subscription service makes the $20 individual price tag for these two games seem excessive.

Availability and Pricing

Pokémon FireRed and Pokémon LeafGreen are available for purchase individually on the Nintendo eShop for $20 each. There is no bundle offer announced at this time.

Specs & Key Features

  • Platform: Nintendo Switch
  • Games: Pokémon FireRed, Pokémon LeafGreen
  • Original Release: Game Boy Advance
  • Features: Original gameplay, local wireless play
  • Price: $20 each
  • Availability: Digital download via Nintendo eShop

Source: Classic Pokemon is Coming to Switch…but at a Cost (YouTube)

Leave a Comment