Foxworth’s ‘My Guy’ List: Uncovering Draft Gems

Foxworth’s ‘My Guy’ List: Uncovering Draft Gems

The NFL Draft is a wild guessing game, and sometimes, the best players aren’t the ones everyone talks about. On The Dominique Foxworth Show, host Dominique Foxworth, along with guests Charlie Kravis and Joe, dove into their personal ‘my guy’ lists – players they believe in, even if the rest of the football world doesn’t see it yet. It’s a deep dive into what makes a prospect special, and how personal evaluation can sometimes beat the crowd.

The ‘My Guy’ Philosophy

The idea of a ‘my guy’ in the draft is simple: it’s a player you love more than the general consensus. It’s about trusting your gut and your scouting. Dominique explained that sometimes, a player might be a mainstream name, but they were your ‘guy’ first, meaning you liked them more than others. It’s about betting your reputation on a player’s potential.

This concept has a history. Dominique recalled the 2018 draft, where he famously declared Lamar Jackson as the future of quarterbacking. He also admitted to being wrong about Josh Allen early on, labeling him a ‘not my guy’ for a time before acknowledging his incredible growth.

“He was a not your guy.” – Dominique Foxworth on Josh Allen

Charlie chimed in with his own draft memories, mentioning the debate around Daniel Jones. While Jones eventually got a second contract, the initial draft pick was a point of contention, highlighting how opinions can evolve.

Personal Biases and Evolving Evaluations

The hosts openly discussed their own scouting biases. Dominique admitted he’s a sucker for 40-yard dash times, a trait he connects to his own athletic past. He’s working to overcome this bias, especially when evaluating players who are smaller but incredibly fast.

Charlie shared his struggles with projecting defensive backs, feeling more confident in evaluating receivers. He also noted that offensive line evaluation often comes down to technique, while defensive backs rely more on learned skills. For defensive front players, he felt more confident, citing Braden Fisk as a ‘my guy’ who proved successful.

Historic ‘My Guys’ and Lessons Learned

The conversation turned to past ‘my guys’ that either panned out or didn’t. Joe brought up Mina Kimes’ reaction to the Daniel Jones pick, a debate that lingered for years. Dominique reflected on his own takes, like being high on Christian Gonzalez, believing he was as good as Witherspoon, who went much higher in the draft.

A fun debate sparked when discussing Marvin Harrison Jr. and Brock Bowers. Dominique initially felt Marvin Harrison Jr. had Hall of Fame talent, but Charlie countered, arguing Brock Bowers was the top pass-catcher in that draft. This friendly disagreement showcased how even the best evaluators can have differing opinions on top prospects.

This Year’s Top ‘My Guys’

Looking at the upcoming draft class, the hosts highlighted several players they’re high on:

• Jordan Tyson (Wide Receiver): Both Charlie and Dominique agree on Tyson, despite injury concerns. They see him as the best receiver in the draft, praising his versatility and explosiveness. Joe even called him the best receiver in college football early last season.
• Caleb Banks (Defensive Lineman): Dominique’s top ‘my guy’ is Banks. He’s a massive and athletic defensive lineman, drawing comparisons to Jordan Davis. Despite coming off foot surgery and having lower production last season, Dominique sees a high floor and league-dominating ceiling for him.
• Ruben Bane (Edge Rusher): While highly touted, Bane is considered a ‘safe stock’ by Dominique. He has a high floor and ceiling, with a demeanor and playing style that easily translates to the NFL.
• Gaylen Kilgore (Safety): Charlie’s top pick is Kilgore, a physical and athletic safety with good speed. He’s compared to a bigger Jaden Barron and is seen as a potential quality starter, likely to be drafted lower than his talent suggests.

The ‘my guy’ concept is more than just picking a player; it’s about understanding the nuances of evaluation, acknowledging personal biases, and trusting your instincts in the unpredictable world of NFL scouting. These players, whether they become stars or not, represent the conviction of the evaluators who believe in their potential.

Source: Underrated 2026 NFL Draft prospects we're highest on | The Domonique Foxworth Show (YouTube)