Ed Miliband’s Quiet Influence: Is He Labour’s Real Power Broker?

Miliband’s Enduring Political Footprint

In the often-turbulent world of British politics, Ed Miliband has emerged as a figure of significant, yet frequently underestimated, influence. Despite facing past electoral setbacks and ongoing public scrutiny, Miliband’s ideas and long-term vision for the country continue to shape the political landscape. This enduring presence has led some to question whether he is, in fact, a key ideological force within the current Labour government, even if he doesn’t seek the top job himself.

The “Milibandism” Effect

Journalist Will Lloyd, who has spent considerable time observing and speaking with Miliband and those around him, argues that “Milibandism” is a guiding principle for the present Labour leadership. He suggests that both the Chancellor and the Prime Minister, and even many within the Conservative party, have been influenced by Miliband’s thinking. Lloyd states, “Whatever you think about what Miliband is doing now and what he’s done in the past, his staying power in parliament in our politics, his ability to generate ideas that become very influential and his long-term idea of what this country could be.” He believes Miliband is unique in this regard, asserting, “I really, really don’t think there’s anyone else like him.” This perspective challenges the common perception of Miliband as a figure from the past, positioning him as a central architect of current policy.

A Visionary or Unpopular Ideologue?

Miliband’s focus on green energy and long-term environmental strategies has often placed him at odds with popular opinion and conservative arguments. While businesses and some segments of the public express concerns about the cost and practicality of these policies, Miliband has persisted with his vision. Charlotte Ivers, a journalist, notes the rarity of such ideological commitment in modern politics. “We have had generations of politicians who are desperately cleaving towards what focus groups take, cleaving towards the center ground. And as Will says, we’re looking at something quite different here. And he has an ideology. He has an agenda. It’s not just one policy. It is an entire vision, as Will says, for how Britain should be.”

“Whether you like that or not is for everyone to decide. But I’m quite impressed by that in a way. I find it quite interesting listening to Will.”

The Shadow of Past Defeats

Despite his current influence, the memory of Miliband’s unsuccessful bid for Prime Minister in 2015 looms large. Some argue that his charisma did not translate well to a national audience, leading to his defeat. “The argument would actually be taking all the points you’ve both made there is that when he was tested in a general election, he resoundedly failed,” one commentator noted. “As a charismatic figure, I suspect he doesn’t necessarily play well across the country as a whole.” This raises questions about his potential to lead the party in a future general election, especially if current leader Keir Starmer were to step aside.

Does Miliband Want the Top Job?

While his influence is widely discussed, there is significant debate about whether Ed Miliband himself desires the position of Prime Minister. Some believe his current focus is on shaping policy rather than seeking leadership. “I do not think Ed Miliband wants to be prime minister. I really, really think he said that to us on this show,” one participant stated. Others, however, suggest that those close to him believe he might be open to the possibility, though he himself has expressed a desire to avoid the intense scrutiny that comes with the role. Angela Rayner, another prominent Labour figure, is also discussed in this context, with suggestions that the demanding nature of the Prime Minister’s job makes it “not a desirable job” for many, including herself.

Questions Around Prime Minister’s Questions (PMQs)

The effectiveness and purpose of Prime Minister’s Questions (PMQs) were also a topic of discussion. With Prime Minister Rishi Sunak increasingly deflecting direct answers, some question the value of the weekly session. “I can certainly see the case that PMQs is a bit of a waste of time now,” one commentator observed. However, others defended its role in revealing politicians’ characters under pressure. “It shows you something about politicians that I think you struggle to get elsewhere, which is an insight into their characters under pressure.” The preparation, the delivery, and the ability to handle difficult questions, or even avoid them, are seen as crucial elements that can impact a leader’s credibility.

The House of Lords vs. The Commons

The debate extended to the broader functioning of Parliament. While the House of Commons was criticized for a perceived decline in the quality of debate, with MPs often reading from screens or relying on prepared questions, the House of Lords received praise for its thorough examination of legislation. “Whatever you think about the House of Lords and where they come from and how they got there, you actually see proper debate and proper conversation and they actually go through with a fine tooth comb.” This suggests a potential disparity in the seriousness and depth of parliamentary scrutiny between the two chambers.

The Moweeni Phone Incident

The conversation also touched upon the recent incident involving the theft of a mobile phone belonging to Morgan Moweeni, the Prime Minister’s Chief of Staff. The Met Police’s decision to release a transcript of Moweeni’s call to the police has fueled speculation. Some theories suggest Moweeni may have deliberately lost the phone to avoid revealing its contents. The incident has added to the intrigue surrounding Moweeni, who is sometimes referred to as “the Irishman” in political circles, evoking a sense of mystery and intrigue.

Looking Ahead: Energy and Elections

As the political landscape evolves, a significant debate is anticipated around energy policy. Labour appears eager to confront the Conservatives and Reform UK on this issue, seeing it as a key battleground for the next election. The coming months will likely see these arguments intensify, offering a clearer view of the parties’ strategies and priorities as they prepare for potential electoral contests.

Source: 'It’s Not A Desirable Job': Why Rayner & Miliband Don't Want To Be Prime Minister | Charlotte Ivers (YouTube)